Menu
= spicy 
= vegetarian
NY-Style
Hand Tossed-
-
Traditional Cheese
tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Medium $21.00
Large $24.00
Gluten Free $23.00
-
Grandma
crushed tomato, garlic, basil, light mozzarella & our original pecorino romano crust
Medium $23.00
Large $27.00
Gluten-Free $25.00
-
Mr. White
garlic olive oil, oregano, romano, ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella cheese.
Medium $26.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $28.00
-
Blanco Veggie
garlic olive oil, spinach, broccoli, white onion, tomato, oregano, ricotta, romano, parmesan & mozzarella cheese
Medium $29.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $31.00
-
BBQ Chicken
smoky bbq sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, cilantro & mozzarella cheese
Medium $27.00
Large $31.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
Deluxe
tomato sauce, mild sausage, canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, green bell pepper, red onion, black olive & mozzarella cheese
Medium $31.00
Large $35.00
Gluten-Free $33.00
-
Florentine
tomato sauce, spinach, broccoli, mushroom, red onion, green bell pepper, tomato, mozzarella & romano cheese
Medium $26.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $28.00
-
Joe P
grandma sauce, mild sausage, white onion, red bell pepper, basil, romano & mozzarella cheese
Medium $28.00
Large $32.00
Gluten-Free $30.00
-
Butcher
tomato sauce, american bacon, mild sausage, canadian bacon, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese
Medium $29.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $31.00
-
Miss Green
pesto cream sauce, spinach, broccoli, zucchini, artichoke, nutmeg, ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella cheese
Medium $29.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $31.00
-
Syracuse-Style Hot Wing
creamy hot sauce, grilled chicken, parsley & mozzarella cheese
Medium $27.00
Large $31.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
The Notorious (SMG)
mild & spicy sausage, mushroom, chili flakes, garlic & mozzarella cheese
Medium $28.00
Large $32.00
Gluten-Free $30.00
-
Primo
tomato sauce, pepperoni, mushroom, jalapeno, garlic, chili flakes & mozzarella cheese
Medium $28.00
Large $32.00
Gluten-Free $30.00
Appetizers
-
Garlic Knots
tossed in garlic olive oil, oregano, parsley & romano cheese. served with marinara sauce
(6) $6.25
(12) $12.50
-
Hot Wings
choose one sauce: mild, spicy or bbq
(6) $9.50
(12) $19.00
-
Meatballs
beef & pork meatballs with marinara sauce, romano & mozzarella cheese
(2) $8.50
(4) $16.95
-
Pesto Garlic Knots
our garlic knots baked with pesto cream sauce & mozzarella cheese
(6) $8.25
(12) $16.50
Sicilian
Deep Dish-
Tomato PIe
homestyle pizza with marinara sauce, romano cheese, parsley & olive oil. no mozzarella cheese
$25.00
-
Sicilian Cheese
tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese & oregano
$30.00
-
Utica
tomato sauce over mozzarella cheese with pepperoni, oregano, romano, hot honey & pesto cream drizzle
$36.00
-
Great Grandma
homestyle margarita with tomato, garlic, basil, oregano, romano & mozzarella cheese
$33.00
By the Slice
-
Cheese
$3.25
-
Pepperoni
$3.50
-
Tomato Pie
home-style, square pan pizza with marinara sauce & grated romano cheese. No mozzarella
$3.50
-
House Pies
signature pies made on our ny-style crust
$4.00 - $4.50
Calzones
crescent moon turnover filled with ricotta & mozzarella cheese. served with marinara-
Custom
your choice of three toppings. (make it vegan +2)
$22.00
-
Meat
pepperoni, canadian bacon, mild sausage & american bacon
$23.00
-
Veggie
spinach, mushroom, red onion, green bell pepper & broccoli
$23.00
Toppings
-
Cheese (All Pasteurized)
feta, mozzarella, vegan, shaved parmesan, ricotta, romano
-
Meats (Free of Hormones, Antibiotics & Msg)
anchovy, american bacon, canadian bacon, chicken, meatball, pepperoni, mild sausage
-
Vegetables
artichoke, basil, black olive, broccoli, cilantro, fresh jalapeño, garlic, green bell pepper, mushroom, pepperoncini, pineapple, red onion, spinach, tomato, zucchini
Fresh Green Salads
-
Add Grilled Chicken + $4.50
-
Caesar
romaine lettuce, heirloom tomato, croutons, shaved parmesan cheese & caesar dressing
$10.50
-
Mediterranean
farm greens, avocado, black olive, heirloom tomato, red onion, garbanzo beans, cucumber, feta cheese & lemon vinaigrette
$13.95
-
House Salad
farm greens, heirloom tomato, cucumber, carrots, garbanzo beans & ranch dressing
$10.00
Drinks
-
Vintage Sodas
mexican coke & squirt, vanilla cream, root beer
$3.95
-
Water
acqua panna or san pellegrino
$3.50
-
Orangina
$3.75
-
Unsweetened Green Tea
$3.75
Desserts
-
New York Cheesecake
$6.00
-
Chocolate Cannoli
$5.50
Pizza
Hand Tossed Ny-Style
-
Traditional Cheese
Tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
14'' $21.00
18'' $24.00
-
Vegan Cheese
Tomato sauce & follow your heart vegan mozzarella cheese
14'' $23.00
18'' $27.00
-
Grandma
Crushed tomato, garlic, basil, light mozzarella & our original pecorino romano crust
14" $23.00
18'' $27.00
-
Mr. White
Garlic olive oil, oregano, romano, ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella cheese
14'' $26.00
18'' $30.00
-
Blanco Veggie
Garlic olive oil, spinach, broccoli, white onion, tomato, oregano, ricotta, romano, parmesan & mozzarella cheese
14'' $29.00
18'' $33.00
-
Miss Green
Pesto cream sauce, spinach, broccoli, zucchini, artichoke, nutmeg, ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella cheese
14'' $29.00
18'' $33.00
-
Florentine
Tomato sauce, spinach, broccoli, mushroom, red onion, green bell pepper, tomato, mozzarella & romano cheese
14'' $26.00
18'' $30.00
-
Really Really Funghi
Garlic olive oil, mushroom, zucchini, heirloom tomato, red onion, pesto cream drizzle, feta & mozzarella cheese
14'' $29.00
18'' $33.00
-
Syracuse
Creamy hot sauce, grilled chicken, parsley & mozzarella cheese
14'' $27.00
18'' $31.00
-
BBQ Chicken
Smokey bbq sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, cilantro & mozzarella cheese
14'' $27.00
18'' $31.00
-
Deluxe
Tomato sauce, mild sausage, canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, green bell pepper, red onion, black olive & mozzarella cheese
14'' $31.00
18'' $35.00
-
Butcher
Tomato sauce, american bacon, mild sausage, canadian bacon, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese
14'' $29.00
18'' $33.00
-
Joe P.
Grandma sauce, mild sausage, white onion, red bell pepper, basil, romano & mozzarella cheese
14'' $28.00
18'' $32.00
-
Primo
Tomato sauce, pepperoni, mushroom, jalapeño, garlic, chili flakes & mozzarella cheese
14'' $28.00
18'' $32.00
-
The Notorious (SMG)
Mild & spicy sausage, mushroom, chili flakes, garlic & mozzarella cheese
14'' $28.00
18'' $32.00
Deep Dish Sicilian
-
Cheese
Tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese & oregano
18'' $30.00
-
Tomato Pie
Homestyle pizza with marinara sauce, romano cheese, parsley & olive oil. no mozzarella cheese
18'' $25.00
-
Great Grandma
Homestyle margherita with tomato, garlic, basil, oregano, romano & mozzarella cheese
18'' $33.00
-
Utica
Tomato sauce over mozzarella cheese with pepperoni, oregano, romano, hot honey & pesto cream drizzle
18'' $36.00
Calzones
Crescent moon turnover filled with ricotta & mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara-
Custom
Your choice of three toppings
$22.00
(make it vegan) $4.00
-
Meat
Pepperoni, canadian bacon, mild sausage, american bacon, cheese
$23.00
-
Veggie
Spinach, mushroom, red onion, green bell pepper, broccoli
$23.00
Additional Toppings
-
Meats
Anchovy
American bacon
Canadian bacon
Chicken
Meatball
Mild sausage
Pepperoni
Salami
Spicy sausage
-
Cheese
Feta
Mozzarella
Parmesan
Ricotta
Romano
Vegan
-
Vegetables
Artichoke
Basil
Black olive
Broccoli
Cilantro
Garlic
Green bell pepper
Heirloom tomato
Hot italian pepper
Jalapeño
Mushroom
Pepperoncini
Pineapple
Red bell pepper
Red onion
Spinach
White onion
Zucchini
Gluten-Free
Any of our pizza combinations can be made on our 14” gluten-free crust made with rice & potato flour. Add $2 to 14” price
VEGAN
Substitute listed cheese with follow your heart 100% vegan mozzarella or request no cheese and let the sauce be the star of the show
Pastas
served with 2 Garlic Knots Gluten-Free Penne Available +1.25-
Spaghetti
Sicilian-style marinara sauce
$11.50
Add each meatballs $3.50
-
Pappardelle Alfredo
Classic creamy alfredo sauce, parsley, romano & parmesan cheese
$17.75
-
Chicken Riggies
Spicy tomato cream sauce, chicken, hot italian pepper, green bell pepper, red onion & rigatoni pasta
$17.75
-
Baked Ziti
Marinara sauce with layers of ricotta, romano & mozzarella cheese
$16.75
-
Penne Pomodoro
Light tomato sauce, garlic, basil & parmesan cheese. Made spicy on request
$14.50
-
Rigatoni with Meat Sauce
Slow cooked tomato sauce with beef & pork
$16.00
-
Kids Pasta
Butter & romano cheese sauce with spaghetti or penne pasta
$10.50
-
gluten-free penne available $1.50
Salads
-
House Green
Farm greens, heirloom tomato, cucumber, carrots, garbanzo beans, croutons & ranch dressing
$10.00
-
Caesar
Romaine lettuce, heirloom tomato, garbanzo beans, shaved parmesan cheese & caesar dressing
$10.50
-
Mediterranean
Farm greens, avocado, black olive, heirloom tomato, red onion, garbanzo beans, cucumber, feta cheese & lemon vinaigrette
$13.95
Appetizers
-
Garlic Knots
Tossed in olive oil, garlic & romano cheese
(6) $6.25
(12) $12.50
-
Pesto Garlic Knots
Our garlic knots baked with pesto cream sauce & mozzarella cheese
(6) $8.25
(12) $16.50
-
Hot Wings
Baked and not too spicy
(6) $9.50
(12) $19.00
-
Meatballs
Made with pork, beef, breadcrumbs, marinara, romano & mozzarella cheese
(2) $8.50
(4) $16.95
-
Broccolini Limone
Broccolini, spinach, mushroom, cherry tomato, garlic & lemon drizzle
$12.50
-
Sauces
Pizza $1.00
Ranch $1.25
Marinara $1.00
Hot $1.25
Syracuse $1.25
Pesto cream $1.25
Subs
Served Toasted-
Meatball
Beef & pork meatballs, marinara, parsley, romano & mozzarella cheese
$13.00
-
Italian
Capicola, salami, pepperoni, lettuce, red onion, hot italian pepper, mayonnaise & parmesan cheese
$13.00
Vintage Soda
Natural Sugar Cane $3.95-
Mexican coke
Mexican squirt
Vanilla cream
Root beer
Soda Cans
$2.75-
Coca cola
Diet coke
Sprite
Waters
$3.50-
Acqua panna
San pellegrino
San pellegrino limonata
San pellegrino aranciata
Other
$3.75-
Orangina
Martinelli apple juice
Green tea
Desserts
-
New York Cheesecake
$6.00
-
Chocolate Layered Cake
$7.00
-
Canoli
$5.50
ORDERING & GENERAL INFO
Whether you are coming together for a kids party, the Super Bowl, the Academy Awards or any type of event, Tomato Pie is here to help. We have the most authentic NY-Style pizza around, and we also serve larger portions of our delicious pastas, subs, and salads.
Choose between a small tray serving 10 people or a large tray serving 20 people. Pizzas can be cut into different slice configurations to accommodate your specific needs. We can customize most items to be sensitive to gluten or dairy allergies as well as make them kid-friendly.
Our drop-off catering is delivered in recyclable pans and cardboard boxes and can be arranged in a simple buffet-style upon delivery. We offer disposable plates, napkins, and utensils upon request.
All orders should be placed at least 24 hours before the event. Please allow a ten minute grace period for requested timed orders.
Our delivery fee is $5.99 for orders within our normal three-mile range. Additional charges apply for longer distances.
Credit card authorization required at time of ordering. A 10% gratuity is added to all deliveries over $150.
Please check our online menu for complete ingredients. Some items are not available at all locations.
APPETIZERS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Garlic Knots
Served with marinara on the side
$19.00
$37.00
-
Hot Wings
Served with ranch on the side
$60.00
$120.00
-
Meatballs
$68.00
$136.00
-
Broccolini Limone
$63.00
$125.00
FRESH GREEN SALADS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Antipasto
With balsamic vinaigrette
$43.00
$85.00
-
Caesar
With creamy caesar dressing
$33.00
$66.00
-
Mediterranean
With lemon vinaigrette
$45.00
$89.00
-
Add Grilled Chicken
$10.00
$20.00
SUBS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
$60.00
$120.00
-
Italian
-
Meatball
-
Chicken
STROMBOLI
24 slices | Similar to a calzone but longer and perfect for parties. Served with sides of ranch and marinara sauce.-
$34.00
-
Custom
Choose any four ingredients from the pie toppings list. Comes with mozzarella cheese
-
The Butcher
Pepperoni, american bacon, canadian bacon, mild sausage & mozzarella cheese
-
Vegetarian
Spinach, broccoli, onion, bell pepper, tomato, ricotta & mozzarella cheese
PASTAS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Pasta Marinara
Spaghetti, penne or rigatoni
$46.00
$91.00
-
Rigatoni with Meat Sauce
$58.00
$112.00
-
Penne with Pesto Cream
$72.00
$136.00
-
Alfredo
Penne or Pappardelle pasta
$74.00
$144.00
-
Chicken Riggies
$70.00
$130.00
-
Baked Ziti
$66.00
$124.00
-
Add Chicken
$10.00
$20.00
-
Change Pasta to Gluten Free Penne
$3.50
$7.00
Hand Tossed NY-Style
-
Traditional Cheese
Medium $21.00
Large $24.00
Gluten Free $23.00
-
Grandma
Medium $24.00
Large $27.00
Gluten-Free $26.00
-
Mr. White
Medium $25.00
Large $28.00
Gluten-Free $27.00
-
Blanco Veggie
Medium $31.00
Large $34.00
Gluten-Free $33.00
-
Miss Green
Medium $29.00
Large` $32.00
Gluten-Free $31.00
-
Florentine
Medium $25.00
Large $28.00
Gluten-Free $27.00
-
Really Really Funghi
Medium $29.00
Large $33.00
Gluten Free $31.00
-
Syracuse
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
The Notorious (SMG)
Medium $28.00
Large $31.00
Gluten-Free $30.00
-
Primo
Medium $30.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $32.00
-
BBQ Chicken
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
Deluxe
Medium $31.00
Large $35.00
Gluten-Free $34.00
-
Joe P
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
Butcher
Medium $30.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $32.00
Deep Dish Sicilian-Style
-
Sicilian Cheese
$30.00
-
Tomato Pie
$25.00
-
Great Grandma
$33.00
-
Utica
$36.00
Pizza Toppings
-
Cheese, All Pasteurized
Cheddar, vegan, feta, mozzarella, shaved parmesan, ricotta, romano
-
Vegetables
Artichoke, basil, banana pepper, black olive, broccoli, cilantro, garlic, green bell pepper, heirloom tomatoes, hot italian pepper, jalapeño, mushroom, pineapple, red bell pepper, roasted garlic, spinach, white onion, zucchini
-
Meats, Free of Hormones, Antibiotics & Msg
Anchovy, american bacon, canadian bacon, chicken, meatball, pepperoni, salami, mild sausage, spicy sausage